Sildenafil vs Tadalafil

Quick Overview

Both sildenafil (Viagra) and tadalafil (Cialis) are highly effective ED medications that work by the same mechanism—increasing blood flow to the penis. They’re both FDA-approved, safe when used correctly, and have similar success rates (70-85%).

The main differences:

• Duration: Tadalafil lasts much longer (up to 36 hours vs 4-6 hours)
• Timing: Sildenafil needs more precise timing; tadalafil offers more flexibility
• Daily use: Tadalafil available as low-dose daily medication; sildenafil is not
• Food interactions: Tadalafil less affected by food
• Cost: Sildenafil often slightly cheaper

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Sildenafil (Viagra)	Tadalafil (Cialis)
Brand Name	Viagra	Cialis
How It Works	PDE5 inhibitor	PDE5 inhibitor
Effectiveness	70-85% of men	70-85% of men
Time to Work	30-60 minutes	30 minutes
Duration	4-6 hours	Up to 36 hours
Available Doses	25mg, 50mg, 100mg	5mg, 10mg, 20mg (on-demand) 2.5mg, 5mg (daily)
Daily Use Option	No	Yes (2.5mg or 5mg)
Food Interaction	Fatty meals delay effect	Minimal food interaction
Alcohol	Can reduce effectiveness	Can reduce effectiveness
Common Side Effects	Headache, flushing, nasal congestion, vision changes	Headache, flushing, back pain, muscle aches
Generic Cost	$2-8 per dose	$2.50-10 per dose
Nickname	”The Blue Pill"	"The Weekend Pill”

How They Work

Same Mechanism, Different Duration

Both medications are PDE5 inhibitors (phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors). Here’s how they work:

1. During sexual arousal, the body releases nitric oxide in the penis
2. Nitric oxide activates an enzyme that produces cGMP, which relaxes smooth muscles and allows blood to flow into the penis
3. Normally, an enzyme called PDE5 breaks down cGMP, ending the erection
4. Sildenafil and tadalafil block PDE5, allowing cGMP levels to remain high, maintaining blood flow and facilitating an erection

Important: Both medications require sexual stimulation to work. They don’t cause automatic erections.

Detailed Comparison

Duration of Action

Sildenafil (Viagra)

• Effects last 4-6 hours
• Best for planned sexual activity
• Need to time dosing carefully (30-60 minutes before sex)
• Effects wear off relatively quickly

Tadalafil (Cialis)

• Effects last up to 36 hours (“weekend pill”)
• Allows for more spontaneity
• Can take in the morning and be ready all day and night
• Don’t need to time sex as precisely

Winner for spontaneity: Tadalafil

Daily Use Option

Sildenafil

• Only available as on-demand treatment
• Take before planned sexual activity
• Not designed for daily use

Tadalafil

• Available in low doses (2.5mg or 5mg) for daily use
• Maintains steady levels in the system
• Allows complete spontaneity—no planning needed
• May help with urinary symptoms from enlarged prostate (BPH)

Winner for daily use: Tadalafil (only option)

Onset of Action

Sildenafil

• Takes 30-60 minutes to work
• Peak effect at 60 minutes
• Fatty meals can delay absorption significantly

Tadalafil

• Takes 30 minutes to work
• Can work as quickly as 15-30 minutes for some men
• Less affected by food—can take with or without meals

Winner for fast onset: Tadalafil (slightly faster, more consistent)

Food and Alcohol Interactions

Sildenafil

• Fatty meals significantly delay absorption and reduce effectiveness
• Best taken on empty stomach or after light meal
• High-fat dinner can delay effect by 1-2 hours
• Alcohol reduces effectiveness

Tadalafil

• Minimal food interactions—can take with meals
• Not significantly affected by food timing
• Alcohol still reduces effectiveness (both medications)

Winner for flexibility: Tadalafil

Side Effects

Both medications have similar side effect profiles, but with some differences.

Sildenafil (Viagra) Side Effects

Common:

• Headache (most common)
• Flushing (red face)
• Nasal congestion
• Indigestion
• Blue-tinted vision or light sensitivity (unique to sildenafil)

Tadalafil (Cialis) Side Effects

Common:

• Headache
• Flushing
• Back pain and muscle aches (more common with tadalafil)
• Indigestion
• Nasal congestion

Both medications:

• Side effects usually mild and temporary
• Decrease with continued use
• Can often be managed by adjusting dose
• Rare serious side effects (priapism, sudden vision/hearing loss)

Winner: Tie (similar side effects, just different patterns)

Effectiveness

Both medications are highly effective:

• Success rates: 70-85% of men
• Work for most causes of ED
• Effectiveness similar across both drugs
• Some men respond better to one vs. the other (individual variation)

Winner: Tie (clinically equivalent effectiveness)

Cost Comparison

Generic versions of both medications are now available, making them affordable.

Generic Sildenafil

• $2-8 per dose (depending on dose and source)
• Usually slightly cheaper than tadalafil
• 25mg: ~$2-4
• 50mg: ~$4-6
• 100mg: ~$6-8

Generic Tadalafil

• $2.50-10 per dose (on-demand)
• $1.50-3 per dose (daily, but taken every day)
• 5mg: ~$2.50-4
• 10mg: ~$4-6
• 20mg: ~$6-10
• 2.5mg daily: ~$1.50-2
• 5mg daily: ~$2-3

Brand-Name Versions

• Brand Viagra: $50-70 per pill
• Brand Cialis: $50-70 per pill

Winner for lowest cost: Generic sildenafil (slightly cheaper)

Which Medication Should You Choose?

Choose Sildenafil (Viagra) If You:

• Plan sex in advance and don’t need spontaneity
• Want the lowest cost option
• Prefer a medication that clears your system quickly
• Don’t mind timing your dose carefully
• Want the most well-known, original ED medication

Best for: Planned sexual activity, budget-conscious users, those who want predictable timing

Choose Tadalafil (Cialis) If You:

• Want spontaneity—ready anytime within 36 hours
• Prefer flexibility around meals (can take with food)
• Want a daily option for complete spontaneity
• Have BPH symptoms (enlarged prostate)—tadalafil helps both ED and urinary symptoms
• Don’t want to plan sex in advance

Best for: Spontaneous sex, daily use, those who want maximum flexibility

Still Not Sure?

Many men try both to see which they prefer. Factors to consider:

Individual Response

• Some men respond better to one medication
• Side effects vary person to person
• Trial and error may be needed

Lifestyle Factors

• Frequency of sexual activity
• Meal timing and schedules
• Spontaneity vs. planning
• Budget

Relationship Factors

• Partner’s preferences
• Spontaneity needs
• Frequency of sex

Daily vs. On-Demand Tadalafil

Tadalafil offers a unique option: daily low-dose use.

On-Demand Tadalafil (10mg or 20mg)

Pros:

• Only take when needed
• Higher dose for maximum effectiveness
• Lower overall cost if infrequent sex

Cons:

• Need to plan ahead (take 30 min before)
• Less spontaneous than daily use

Daily Tadalafil (2.5mg or 5mg)

Pros:

• Complete spontaneity—no planning needed
• Steady levels maintain erectile function
• Helps BPH symptoms continuously
• May improve erectile function over time

Cons:

• Take pill every day (even days without sex)
• Higher monthly cost if infrequent sex
• Lower dose means may not work as well for severe ED

Who benefits most from daily tadalafil:

• Men who have sex 2+ times per week
• Those who want maximum spontaneity
• Men with BPH symptoms (enlarged prostate)
• Those in committed relationships with regular intimacy

Combining or Switching Medications

Can You Switch Between Them?

Yes, you can switch between sildenafil and tadalafil based on your needs:

• Use tadalafil for weekends when spontaneity matters
• Use sildenafil for planned occasions to save money
• Try both to see which you prefer

Important: Don’t take both medications at the same time or within 24 hours of each other.

Can You Combine with Testosterone?

If low testosterone contributes to ED, your doctor may prescribe:

• TRT (testosterone replacement therapy) + ED medication
• This combination can be very effective
• Requires medical supervision

What If Neither Works?

If sildenafil and tadalafil don’t work:

• Try different doses
• Ensure proper timing and technique
• Check for underlying health issues
• Consider other PDE5 inhibitors (vardenafil, avanafil)
• Explore alternative treatments (injections, implants)

Safety Considerations

Both Medications Are Contraindicated With:

• Nitrate medications (nitroglycerin, isosorbide)—dangerous interaction that can cause severe blood pressure drop
• Certain heart medications (alpha-blockers)—may need dose adjustment
• Recent stroke or heart attack—wait period required

Tell Your Doctor If You Have:

• Heart disease or heart rhythm problems
• Low blood pressure
• Liver or kidney disease
• Retinitis pigmentosa (eye condition)
• Peyronie’s disease (penile curvature)
• Blood cell disorders (sickle cell, leukemia)

Rare But Serious Side Effects

Seek immediate medical attention if you experience:

• Priapism: Erection lasting more than 4 hours (medical emergency)
• Sudden vision loss: Can indicate NAION (non-arteritic anterior ischemic optic neuropathy)
• Sudden hearing loss: Rare but requires immediate attention
• Chest pain during sex: May indicate heart problem

Where to Get Sildenafil and Tadalafil

Telehealth Services (Most Convenient & Affordable)

Best Overall: Hims offers both generic sildenafil (from $2/dose) and tadalafil (from $2.50/dose) with same-day consultations, flexible subscriptions, and discreet delivery. Great for most men seeking affordable, convenient care.

Best for Daily Tadalafil: Ro provides comprehensive daily tadalafil programs with physician support, health tracking, and flexible dosing options. Ideal if you want ongoing medical support and prefer daily medication for spontaneity.

Best for Chewable Medications: BlueChew specializes in chewable sildenafil and tadalafil with monthly subscriptions ($20-90/month). Perfect if you want the convenience of chewables and don’t need in-person care.

International Options:

• Manual (UK) - Both medications available for UK residents
• Numan (UK) - Comprehensive ED care with flexible options

Compare all ED treatment services to find the best fit for your needs.

Benefits of telehealth: Discreet consultations, medications delivered to your door, often cheaper than traditional healthcare, no in-person visit required, licensed physicians prescribe medications.

Traditional Doctor’s Office

• See primary care doctor or urologist for in-person exam
• May be covered by insurance (though ED medications often aren’t)
• Good option if you have complex health conditions

Local Pharmacy

• Requires prescription from doctor
• Generic versions widely available at CVS, Walgreens, etc.
• Usually not covered by insurance for ED indication

The Bottom Line

Both sildenafil and tadalafil are excellent ED medications with high success rates (70-85%). The choice comes down to personal preference and lifestyle.

Choose Sildenafil (Viagra) if:

• You plan sex in advance
• You want the lowest cost
• You prefer medication that clears quickly

Choose Tadalafil (Cialis) if:

• You value spontaneity (36-hour window)
• You want a daily-use option
• You want flexibility around meals

Many men try both to determine which works better for their body and lifestyle. Both are safe, effective, and available affordably through telehealth services.

Talk to a healthcare provider to determine which medication is right for you.

Related Resources

Treatment Guides:

• Understanding Erectile Dysfunction: Complete Guide
• When to See a Doctor About ED
• Premature Ejaculation Treatment Options

Service Reviews:

• Hims Review - Best pricing on both medications
• Ro Review - Premium daily tadalafil programs
• BlueChew Review - Chewable sildenafil & tadalafil

Popular Comparisons:

• Hims vs Ro - Which offers better value?
• Hims vs BlueChew - Pills vs chewables
• Ro vs BlueChew - Premium vs budget

---

This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider before starting any ED medication.